Payroll rarely arrives as a decision. It arrives as a favor. The founder runs the first one because there is nobody else. Then there are six people, then a grant that pays for half of one of them, then a pastor with a housing allowance, then someone who moved to another state, and one day the founder notices that every other Tuesday belongs to payroll.
At that point most leaders see two choices: keep doing it, or hire someone. There is a third, and it is worth knowing what each one really costs.
What payroll work actually is
Pressing the button is the smallest part. The work is everything around it:
- Collecting hours and getting them approved, on time, from people who are busy.
- New hires, terminations, raises and changes of address, entered before the payroll they affect.
- Garnishments, which arrive by mail and have deadlines of their own.
- Tax deposits and quarterly and yearly filings, in every state where someone works.
- Allocating pay to grants and programs, if your funders ask, and they usually do.
- W-2s in January, and answering the staff who have questions about them.
- Noticing the mistake before it goes out, which is the part nobody sees.
Option one: keep doing it yourself
This works when the staff is small, everyone is in one state, nobody's pay is unusual, and the person doing it has the time and does not mind. It costs no money. It costs attention, and it has one weakness that matters: the whole payroll lives in one head. When that person is sick, on vacation, or simply gone, the payroll is too.
The whole payroll lives in one head. When that person is sick, on vacation, or simply gone, the payroll is too.
Option two: hire someone
A dedicated payroll person makes sense for a larger organization, especially one that also needs that person for HR or accounting, or needs someone on site every day. It is also the most expensive answer. The Bureau of Labor Statistics put the median yearly wage for payroll and timekeeping clerks at $58,260 in May 2025. That is a clerk, not a manager, and it is before the employer's share of payroll taxes, benefits, a desk, software and training. And that person will want a vacation too, which brings back the problem of option one.
Option three: someone outside does the work
In between is a managed service: a payroll person outside your organization who does the work on your payroll platform. You send what changed, they enter it, run it, file it and tell you when something looks wrong. You keep the approvals. It costs less than a hire and more than doing it yourself, and the payroll no longer depends on one person's calendar.
If you look at one, from us or anyone, ask these:
- Who is my person? A name and a phone number, or a ticket queue?
- What do you need from me each payroll, and by when?
- Who files the taxes, and who answers the notice if one comes?
- What happens on a holiday week, or when my person is out?
- What is included, and what is billed on top? Get it in writing.
How to decide
Count the hours payroll takes each month, including the interruptions and the evenings. Put a price on those hours, at the rate of the person doing them. Then ask what that person would do with the time back. For an executive director, the answer is usually the work the organization exists to do: donors, programs, the board. For a pastor, it is the congregation. That is the real comparison, not the invoice.
What we offer
Our Managed Payroll is option three. A Giving Payroll manager handles payroll entry and processing, approvals, new hires, terminations, garnishments and changes, payroll tax filings, W-2s and routine reporting, and watches the deadlines, on ADP or SurePayroll. We know clergy pay and grant allocations, because most of our clients are nonprofits and churches. It starts at $360 a month for one employee, plus a one-time $250 setup and $1.50 per employee per payroll run. There is a calculator on our home page, and we confirm the scope and the final price before you commit to anything.
If you would rather keep payroll in house, that is a fine answer too. What nonprofit payroll should cost covers what to watch for either way.
Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Financial Clerks, median annual wages for May 2025; Giving Payroll, Managed Payroll on the home page. Read November 16, 2026.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.
Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

