Giving Payroll
Who we arePayroll & pricingWhy Giving?Our PartnersPayNonprofits™GivingHR+ NEW
HR+Login
Field NotesPAYROLL PRICING

Low cost nonprofit payroll, without the surprises.

A low price only helps if it is the whole price. Here is how payroll pricing works, where the extra charges hide, and what we publish for nonprofits.

November 14, 2026

How payroll pricing works

Almost every payroll provider charges the same two things: a base fee and a fee for each employee paid. The part that changes is how often you pay them. Some charge every month, some charge every time you run payroll, and a quote can look cheaper than it is until you multiply it out over a year.

So when you compare low cost nonprofit payroll options, turn every quote into one number: what will this cost my organization per year, for my pay schedule and my headcount? If a provider cannot answer that in one sentence, the price is not really low. It is just hard to read.

Where the extra charges hide

  • Setup. A one time charge to load your organization and your people. Ask for it in writing.
  • Year end. Some providers charge extra to prepare and file W-2s. Ask whether year end is in the price.
  • More than one state. Staff in a second state can add tax filing fees. Remote workers count.
  • Paper checks and delivery. Direct deposit is usually included. Printed and shipped checks usually are not.
  • Extra runs. A bonus run or a correction outside your normal schedule may be billed as another payroll.
  • Add-ons you did not ask for. Time tracking, HR tools and workers' compensation are useful, but they should be choices, not surprises.

What low cost should still include

Cheap payroll that leaves the tax filings to you is not a bargain. At Giving Payroll, the published payroll price includes direct deposit, federal, state and local payroll tax filings, quarterly and annual payroll tax returns, W-2 preparation and filing, employee self-service with pay stubs and W-2 access, new hire reporting, and a dedicated account manager who knows your organization.

Our published prices for nonprofits

We put the price on the website because we think you should see it before you talk to anyone. For a nonprofit, each payroll run is a base charge plus a charge for each employee paid:

ProviderWeeklyEvery 2 weeks or twice a monthMonthlyEach employee paidOne time setup
SurePayroll$27$40$64$1.25$50
ADP$29$49$73$1.50$75

A nonprofit paying five people twice a month through SurePayroll pays $46.25 per run: $40 plus five times $1.25. That is 24 runs a year, or $1,110. You pay per run, not an extra monthly fee on top. Optional services, such as shipped paper checks or pay as you go workers' compensation, are separate and named up front.

The price calculator on our home page does this math for your own schedule and headcount, and it always shows the current prices.

A short checklist before you sign

  • Get the yearly total for your pay schedule and headcount.
  • Ask what is not included, and get the list in writing.
  • Ask who answers when you call, and whether it is the same person each time.
  • Ask whether the provider has worked with grants, program allocations or clergy pay, if those apply to you.

If you want a formal number to take to your board, request an official quote and we will put it in a report you can share.

Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

KEEP READINGPayroll for nonprofits: what is different, and what your provider should knowNonprofit HR services: what to hand off, and what to keep

In this post

  1. How payroll pricing works
  2. Where the extra charges hide
  3. What low cost should still include
  4. Our published prices for nonprofits
  5. A short checklist before you sign

Questions about your payroll?

877-245-0345See our prices
Giving Payroll
Payroll pricingGivingHR+Managed servicesContactField NotesTermsPrivacy
© 2026 Giving PayrollGiving great service. Giving great pricing. Giving great payroll.