Wages have to follow the money
A business pays people. A nonprofit pays people out of specific funds. When a program manager spends 60 percent of her week on a grant funded program and the rest on general operations, the books have to show that, and funders will ask. Payroll for nonprofits works best when hours are tracked by program or grant as they are worked, so the allocation is built from what happened and not from a guess at month end.
The same hours feed your Form 990, which asks for expenses split into program services, management and general, and fundraising. Payroll is usually the largest line in all three.
Unemployment tax is different
Organizations that are exempt under section 501(c)(3) do not pay federal unemployment tax. State unemployment is a separate matter: 501(c)(3) organizations can usually choose between paying state unemployment contributions like any employer or reimbursing the state for claims actually paid. Which one is better depends on your size and turnover, and it is worth a conversation with your accountant before you choose.
Clergy pay follows its own rules
Houses of worship have a category of employee nobody else has. Ministers are generally treated as employees for income tax and as self-employed for Social Security and Medicare, so the usual withholding does not apply the usual way. A housing allowance, when it is properly designated, is handled differently again. A provider that has not set up clergy pay before will learn on your payroll.
Volunteers, stipends and small payments
A volunteer who is paid a stipend may have become an employee. Board members, interns, and seasonal program staff all raise the same question. It is easier to get the classification right at the start than to correct a year of filings.
Boards want to see it
Finance committees approve vendors and read reports. Nonprofit payroll should come with a price you can show the board, reports that match how you are funded, and a person who can explain a line item in plain words.
Questions to ask a payroll provider
- Can you track hours by program or grant, and help us allocate payroll from them?
- Have you set up clergy pay and housing allowances?
- Do you know how our state treats unemployment for 501(c)(3) employers?
- Will we have one person who knows our organization?
- Is your price published, and what is not included?
This is the work Giving Payroll was built for. We run payroll for nonprofits, houses of worship and small businesses through ADP and SurePayroll, with a dedicated account manager and prices published up front. For tracking hours by program, GivingHR+ does it from the time clock.
Sources: IRS, Section 501(c)(3) organizations, FUTA exemption; IRS, Topic no. 417, Earnings for clergy; National Council of Nonprofits, Unemployment Insurance.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.
Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

