The IRS uses the word church for every house of worship. Its own guide for churches says it uses the term generically, for a place of worship including mosques and synagogues. So when a synagogue administrator calls a payroll company and hears "we do church payroll," the right answer is "good, then you do ours." The trouble starts when the person on the phone has only ever done the office manager's paycheck.
Here are five things synagogues hear, and what the rules actually say. None of this is about Jewish law. It is about the tax code, which is less interesting and much more strict about dates.
Myth 1: Only the rabbi can be treated as clergy
The IRS treats ministers, priests and rabbis alike: most services a rabbi performs as clergy are ministerial services under the tax rules. A cantor can qualify too. The IRS's guide for clergy says a cantor with a bona fide commission, employed to perform substantially all the religious functions of the Jewish faith, can be treated the same way for the housing allowance.
Whether one particular person qualifies depends on the facts: how they were ordained or commissioned, and what they actually do. The executive director, the bookkeeper and the religious school teachers are ordinary employees, whatever their titles.
Myth 2: Withhold Social Security and Medicare from the rabbi like everyone else
No. A minister's earnings for ministerial services are not subject to Social Security and Medicare withholding. You do not withhold the employee's half and you do not pay the employer's half. Instead the rabbi pays self-employment tax on their own return, even though they are your employee for income tax and get a W-2.
You are not required to withhold income tax from clergy either, but a rabbi or cantor can ask you to, and many do, so that April holds no surprises. A payroll system that treats the rabbi like the office manager takes money that is not owed, and getting it back is slow.
Myth 3: The synagogue owes federal unemployment tax
An organization exempt under section 501(c)(3) is also exempt from federal unemployment tax, and the IRS says the exemption cannot be waived. The IRS's guide for churches says plainly that churches and religious organizations are not liable for it. If someone is filing Form 940 and paying it for you, ask why.
State unemployment is a separate question with a separate answer in every state, so check yours before assuming it works the same way.
Myth 4: The board can approve the housing allowance whenever it gets to it
This is the expensive one. The housing allowance has to be designated by official action before it is paid. In practice that means a board resolution or minutes, with a date, before the first payroll of the year that includes it. A handshake in the parking lot after services is not a designation, and you cannot go back in December and approve the year.
Two more things worth knowing. The amount left out of income tax is the smallest of what was designated, what was actually spent on the home, and the home's fair rental value with furnishings and utilities. And the allowance still counts for self-employment tax, so "tax free" means free of income tax only.
A handshake in the parking lot after services is not a designation.
Myth 5: A synagogue has to apply to the IRS and file a Form 990 like any charity
Churches, including synagogues, temples and mosques, are exempt without applying, and the IRS lists churches among the organizations that do not file the annual Form 990. Many congregations apply for recognition anyway, because a determination letter tells donors in writing that their gifts are deductible. That is a choice, not a requirement.
What a synagogue with staff does file is the same employment tax returns as any employer: Form 941 each quarter, W-2s every January, and state returns where it has people.
What we will ask you
Who is paid and how often. Who is clergy under the rules. The board's housing allowance resolution, dated before the first payment. Whether the rabbi or cantor wants income tax withheld. What state you are in.
The rest of the rules for clergy, and the forms for opting out of Social Security, are in church payroll for every house of worship. The same rules for a mosque are in imam pay is pastor pay. Giving Payroll runs payroll for synagogues and other houses of worship through ADP and SurePayroll, with one account manager who knows your congregation and prices published up front.
Sources: IRS, Publication 1828, Tax Guide for Churches and Religious Organizations; IRS, Publication 517, Social Security and Other Information for Members of the Clergy and Religious Workers (for 2025 returns); IRS, Topic no. 417, Earnings for clergy; IRS, Exempt organizations: What are employment taxes?; IRS, Organizations not required to file Form 1023. Read November 16, 2026.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.
Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

