Giving Payroll
Who we arePayroll & pricingWhy Giving?Our PartnersPayNonprofits™GivingHR+ NEW
HR+Login
Field NotesNONPROFIT PAYROLL

We do not judge the mission. We just run the payroll.

Matching linen robes, a chant at sunrise, a firm belief that a particular comet is coming back for you. If the IRS says you are a 501(c)(3), you get the same payroll as the food pantry down the street.

June 6, 2026. Rewritten November 16, 2026, with every source checked again.

We get asked, now and then, whether there is any kind of organization we will not work with. The honest answer is that we have opinions about deposit deadlines and almost none about missions.

Food pantries, theater companies, rescue shelters for one specific breed of dog, a choir that sings only in the original Latin, a foundation that funds research on a disease most people cannot pronounce, a retreat center where everyone wears identical linen robes and keeps one eye on the sky for a comet that is running late. Every one of them has people to pay on Friday, and every one of them owes the same deposits the same way. That is the part we are good at.

The short version

  • The IRS decides who is a 501(c)(3), and churches are exempt without applying. We only check.
  • Every house of worship and every charity follows the same payroll rules, robes or no robes.
  • Which part of 501(c) you are under decides federal unemployment tax. Only 501(c)(3) is exempt.

Robes or no robes, the rules are the same

The tax code does not grade theology, and neither do we. A cathedral, a storefront church, a mosque, a synagogue, a temple and a group that meets in a field at night to chant at the comet's last known position all follow the same payroll rules, as long as each one qualifies. Every other 501(c)(3) follows the same rules as every other 501(c)(3). Chants, bells, incense, a dress code or none of the above, the deposits are the same, the filings are the same and the deadlines are the same.

So the work is the same too. Nobody gets a discount for being mainstream, and nobody pays extra for owning a telescope.

Nobody gets a discount for being mainstream, and nobody pays extra for owning a telescope.

Who decides whether you are a 501(c)(3)? Not us

The IRS does. Section 501(c)(3) covers organizations formed and run for religious, charitable, scientific, literary or educational purposes, testing for public safety, and a few others. That is a wide door on purpose, and it is not our job to stand in it.

What we do is check that the IRS agrees with you. The IRS's Tax Exempt Organization Search shows an organization's exempt status and filings, including its determination letter, and anyone can use it, including you, before we ask.

Churches are the exception. Churches, including synagogues, temples and mosques, are exempt without applying, so a house of worship may have no letter at all. Many apply anyway, because a letter tells donors in writing that their gifts are deductible. Either way is fine with us. More on that in church payroll for every house of worship.

What we ask before the first payroll

  • Your EIN and your exact legal name, the way the IRS has them. A payroll filed under a name that does not match is a letter waiting to happen.
  • Which part of 501(c) you are under. This one changes the payroll, as the next section shows.
  • Your state accounts, for withholding and for unemployment, in every state where someone works.
  • Who on staff is clergy, if anyone. Ministers are paid under different rules.
  • Who approves each payroll. One name, and a second for the week that person is away.

Where the type of exemption changes the payroll

Federal unemployment tax. An organization exempt under 501(c)(3) is also exempt from federal unemployment tax, and the IRS says that exemption cannot be waived. An organization exempt under any other part of 501(c) is not exempt from it. A social welfare organization, a business league, a social club or a labor organization is tax exempt and still pays federal unemployment tax. That is why we ask which part you are under, not just whether you are exempt.

Social Security and Medicare. Being tax exempt does not change these for your ordinary employees. You withhold the employee's part, deposit it and pay a matching amount, like any employer. The exceptions are about clergy and a church's own election, and they are in the church payroll post linked above.

State unemployment. Every state writes its own rules for nonprofits, and some let an exempt organization pay back the state for actual claims instead of paying the tax. It is worth a look before your first payroll, and it gets more interesting when your staff live in more than one state, which is its own post: multi-state payroll for nonprofits.

And the retirement part

The robes and the rituals were the fun part of the title. The retirement part is real. Public schools, 501(c)(3) organizations and churches can generally set up a 403(b) plan, the nonprofit cousin of a 401(k). Eligible employees of 501(c)(3) organizations and churches can take part, and so can ministers, under rules of their own.

A 403(b) is something payroll touches every single payday: the deferral comes out of the check, the employer contribution goes in, and the limits change most years. We set it up in payroll the way your plan document says, and we keep an eye on the limits so a staff member does not find out about a change from their pay stub.

What we will not ask

We will not ask what you believe, what you are saving, why the robes are linen or when the comet is due. We will not ask whether the mission is a good one. That question belongs to your board, your donors and the IRS, in roughly that order.

We will ask one favor. If the comet does arrive, give us two weeks' notice. A closing organization still owes its final payroll tax returns, and everyone who worked there that year still gets a W-2, wherever they are headed.

We will ask for your EIN, your state account numbers and the name of whoever approves payroll. Giving Payroll runs payroll for nonprofits, churches and small businesses through ADP and SurePayroll, with one account manager who knows your organization and prices published up front.

Sources: IRS, Exempt organization types; IRS, Search for tax exempt organizations; IRS, Organizations not required to file Form 1023; IRS, Exempt organizations: What are employment taxes?; IRS, Retirement plans FAQs regarding 403(b) tax-sheltered annuity plans. Read November 16, 2026.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.

Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

KEEP READINGChurch payroll for every house of worship, and we do mean everyBeyond the bimah: five synagogue payroll mythsPayroll for nonprofits: what is different, and what your provider should know

In this post

  1. Robes or no robes, the rules are the same
  2. Who decides whether you are a 501(c)(3)? Not us
  3. What we ask before the first payroll
  4. Where the type of exemption changes the payroll
  5. And the retirement part
  6. What we will not ask

Questions about your payroll?

877-245-0345See our prices
Giving Payroll
Payroll pricingGivingHR+Managed servicesContactField NotesTermsPrivacy
© 2026 Giving PayrollGiving great service. Giving great pricing. Giving great payroll.