Every nonprofit has the list. The Sunday pianist. The grant writer who comes in two days a week. The guest speaker at the spring luncheon. The summer camp counselors. The bookkeeper who is "basically a contractor." Some of them are contractors and some of them are employees, and the label on the paperwork is not what decides it.
Worker classification is not exciting, but getting it wrong is one of the quickest ways to owe back taxes for people you thought you were not employing. Here is how it works.
The IRS question: who controls the work?
For federal taxes, the IRS uses the common law rules. It looks at all the evidence of control and independence, and sorts it into three groups:
- Behavioral control. Can you direct what work is done and how it is done, through instructions, training or other means? Setting the hours, the method and the order of the work points toward an employee.
- Financial control. Who pays the expenses and provides the tools? Can the worker offer the same service to others, set their price, and make or lose money on the job? A worker with their own business, their own clients and their own equipment points toward a contractor.
- Relationship of the parties. What do the agreements say, are there benefits, is the work ongoing, and is it a key part of what your organization regularly does?
No single fact settles it. The question underneath all three is whether you have the right to control not just the result, but how the work gets done.
What a contract can and cannot do
A written contract shows what both sides intended, and that counts. It does not override what actually happens. If the "contractor" works set hours at your office, uses your laptop, follows your procedures and has done so for three years, the contract is a piece of paper describing a different job.
The Department of Labor asks its own question
Minimum wage and overtime come under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and the Department of Labor has its own test for it, built around economic reality: is the worker in business for themselves, or economically dependent on you?
On February 26, 2026, the Department proposed rescinding its 2024 rule on this and returning to an approach like its 2021 one. The proposal names two core factors, the nature and degree of control over the work, and the worker's opportunity for profit or loss based on initiative or investment. Other factors include the skill the work takes, how permanent the relationship is, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production. The comment period ran to April 28, 2026. A proposal is not a rule, so check the Department's page for where it stands before relying on it.
Your state may ask a third question
States decide classification for their own taxes and unemployment, and some use a stricter test. California's ABC test, for example, treats a worker as an employee unless the hiring organization shows all three: the worker is free from its control in doing the work, the work is outside the usual course of its business, and the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established business of the same kind. A worker can pass the IRS test and fail a state one.
The usual suspects
- The guest speaker who gives one talk, prepares it their own way and speaks at other places too usually looks like a contractor.
- The music director or pianist who plays every week, at your times, for your services, under your direction usually looks like an employee.
- Seasonal and camp staff who work your schedule under your supervision look like employees, however short the season.
- The board member who also does the books for pay is judged on the work, not the board seat.
- Clergy have rules of their own, covered in church payroll for every house of worship.
These are tendencies, not answers. The facts of each arrangement decide it.
Paying a contractor properly
Get a Form W-9 before the first payment, not in January. Then report what you paid on Form 1099-NEC. The reporting threshold is $2,000 for payments made after December 31, 2025, up from $600, so the one-time speaker with a small honorarium may no longer need a form at all. More on that and the other 2026 changes is in nonprofit payroll updates.
If you are not sure, or you got it wrong
You can ask the IRS to decide for a specific worker by filing Form SS-8.
If you have been treating workers as contractors and want to treat them as employees from now on, the IRS has a Voluntary Classification Settlement Program. An eligible employer, which can include a tax-exempt organization, pays 10 percent of the employment tax that would have been due on those workers' pay for the most recent tax year, figured at reduced rates, with no interest or penalties, and is not audited on those workers' classification for earlier years. It is applied for on Form 8952, at least 120 days before the date you want to start, and there are conditions, including having filed the 1099s for those workers for the past three years.
What we will ask
When you add someone, we will ask how the work happens, not what you would like to call it. Who sets the hours, who supplies the tools, whether they work for anyone else, and how long it will last. Giving Payroll runs payroll for nonprofits, churches and small businesses through ADP and SurePayroll, with one account manager who knows your organization and prices published up front.
Sources: IRS, Topic no. 762, Independent contractor vs. employee; U.S. Department of Labor, news release of February 26, 2026, on the proposed independent contractor rule; California Labor and Workforce Development Agency, ABC Test; IRS, Form 1099-NEC and independent contractors; IRS, Voluntary Classification Settlement Program. Read November 16, 2026.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.
Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.
The contract is a piece of paper describing a different job.
>
