Giving Payroll
Who we arePayroll & pricingWhy Giving?Our PartnersPayNonprofits™GivingHR+ NEW
HR+Login
Field NotesNONPROFIT PAYROLL

Seven payroll mistakes nonprofits make, and the fix for each.

None of these come from bad people. They come from good people doing payroll as their fifth job. Here is what goes wrong, and what to do about it on Monday.

November 14, 2026

Payroll for nonprofits goes wrong in the same seven places, over and over. Not one of them is exotic. Every one of them is cheaper to fix now than after a letter arrives.

1. The contractor who is really an employee

The grant writer who works your hours, uses your laptop, sits in your staff meeting and has done so for three years is probably not an independent contractor, whatever the agreement says. The IRS looks at three things: whether you control how the work is done, whether you control the money side of the job, and what the relationship between you looks like, including how permanent it is and whether the work is a key part of what you do.

The fix: go down your list of 1099 people and ask those three questions honestly. If you cannot tell, either side can ask the IRS to decide with Form SS-8. If you already know the answer, the IRS has a Voluntary Classification Settlement Program for employers who want to move people to payroll with partial relief on the back taxes. Ask your accountant about it before you ask us to add them.

2. "She is on salary, so no overtime"

Salary does not cancel overtime. Under the federal rule, an employee is exempt only if the job passes a duties test and the salary is at least $684 a week. That is the figure the Department of Labor put back in the regulations in May 2026, after the higher 2024 rule was thrown out in court. A program assistant on $30,000 a year who works 50 hours in gala week is owed overtime for ten of them.

The fix: list everyone on salary, check the pay against $684 a week, and then check the duties. Several states set a higher line than the federal one, and the higher one wins.

3. Staff who "volunteer" at their own job

Your people believe in the mission, so they stay late and call it volunteering. The Department of Labor does not see it that way. Paid employees of a nonprofit cannot volunteer to do the same type of work they are paid to do. Your bookkeeper can volunteer to hand out water at the 5K. She cannot volunteer to close the books.

And do not count on being too small for the rule. A charity's donations do not count toward the $500,000 test that brings a whole organization under the wage law, but an individual employee is covered anyway if their own work crosses state lines, and the Department's examples include making and receiving interstate phone calls.

The fix: if it is their job, it is on the clock. Track the hours, pay the hours, and say thank you as well.

4. Unemployment tax, paid twice or not at all

An organization exempt under section 501(c)(3) does not pay federal unemployment tax. We still find nonprofits that paid it for years because the last payroll setup did not know what they were.

State unemployment is the other half, and it is not automatic either way. Federal law lets 501(c)(3) organizations choose to reimburse the state for benefits actually paid to their former employees, in place of paying regular contributions. One is not always better than the other, and plenty of executive directors have no idea which one a predecessor picked.

The fix: look at last quarter's payroll reports. If you see federal unemployment tax and you are a 501(c)(3), call your provider. Then find the state notice that says whether you are contributing or reimbursing, and ask your accountant whether that still fits your size.

5. Wages charged to a grant by guess

The budget said the program manager would spend 60 percent of her time on the grant, so 60 percent of her pay goes to the grant, every month, forever. If the grant is federal money, that is not good enough. The rule is one sentence long: charges for salaries and wages must be based on records that accurately reflect the work performed. The same rule says budget estimates alone do not qualify as support.

The fix: record time by program as it is worked, and let the split come from the hours. This is exactly why we built GivingHR+ the way we did: people clock in to a program, and the allocation is built from what happened. It also makes your Form 990's functional expenses a report instead of a weekend.

6. The $50 gift card

A holiday ham is a gift. A $50 gift card is wages. The IRS is blunt about it: cash and cash equivalents provided by an employer are never excludable as a small "de minimis" benefit, however small. Its page says in so many words that a gift certificate good for general merchandise is taxable. So that thank you is taxable pay, and it belongs on payroll.

The fix: give the card and tell your payroll provider the same week, so the tax is handled on the next run. Or give the ham.

7. Treating the deposit date as a suggestion

The taxes you withhold from paychecks are not your money. The IRS calls them trust fund taxes because you are holding them in trust. Deposit them late and the penalty starts at 2 percent for one to five days, 5 percent for six to fifteen days, and 10 percent after that, rising to 15 percent if you sit on an IRS notice.

It gets personal after that. When trust fund taxes go unpaid, the IRS can assess the full unpaid amount personally against any responsible person who willfully did not pay it. Its own list of who that can be includes a member of a nonprofit's board of trustees. "Willfully" does not need bad intent. The IRS counts using the money to pay other creditors, the landlord included, as a sign of it.

The fix: let a payroll provider impound and deposit the taxes on every run, so the money leaves the account when the paychecks do. A full service payroll does exactly that.

And one more, from experience

Read the payroll report before you approve it. Every time. We once watched a nonprofit pay a terminated employee for five payrolls because nobody did, and you can read the whole painful story, lessons included.

If you run a house of worship, there is an eighth mistake waiting for you, and it is paying your minister like everybody else. That one has its own article.

Giving Payroll runs payroll for nonprofits through ADP and SurePayroll, with a dedicated account manager who knows your organization and prices published up front. If you are comparing costs, start with what low cost nonprofit payroll should include. And if any of these seven sounded familiar, call us. We have seen it before.

Sources: IRS, Topic no. 762, Independent contractor vs. employee; U.S. Department of Labor, news release of May 14, 2026, on the salary level for exempt employees; U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #14A, Non-Profit Organizations and the Fair Labor Standards Act; IRS, Exempt organizations: What are employment taxes?; U.S. Department of Labor, Unemployment Insurance Program Letter 18-20, on employers that make payments in lieu of contributions; 2 CFR 200.430(g), standards for documentation of personnel expenses; IRS, De minimis fringe benefits; IRS, Failure to deposit penalty; IRS, Employment taxes and the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty. Read November 14, 2026.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules vary by state and situation, so check yours with your accountant or attorney.

Talk to a payroll person. 877-245-0345 or sales@givingpayroll.com. Prices are on the home page.

KEEP READINGThe Lion, the Witch, and the ex-employee that kept the $5,800 payroll errorPayroll for nonprofits: what is different, and what your provider should know

In this post

  1. 1. The contractor who is really an employee
  2. 2. "She is on salary, so no overtime"
  3. 3. Staff who "volunteer" at their own job
  4. 4. Unemployment tax, paid twice or not at all
  5. 5. Wages charged to a grant by guess
  6. 6. The $50 gift card
  7. 7. Treating the deposit date as a suggestion
  8. And one more, from experience

Questions about your payroll?

877-245-0345See our prices
Giving Payroll
Payroll pricingGivingHR+Managed servicesContactField NotesTermsPrivacy
© 2026 Giving PayrollGiving great service. Giving great pricing. Giving great payroll.